Fog Creek Software
Discussion Board

xml schemas anyone?

i need a schema for storing key/value pairs in xml. apple’s proterty lists come to mind: (i work on a mac but need it for web development)

question: do you think it is necessary / good style / helpful to use an existing schema for storing stuff in xml contrary to creating something obscure on my own? can you recommend any schema? any link is welcome!

Friday, February 20, 2004

uh ... aren't key/value pairs pretty much the definition of XML?

You can use the key as the tag and the value as the data?

What am I missing here ...

Matt H.
Friday, February 20, 2004

if you rely on someone elses schema to define your document and they change the schema, you'll have to change your document....just make your own schema

Friday, February 20, 2004

Apple's schema looks similar to the SOAP support in .NET. That's useful for fully automatic (de)serialization of arbitrary data, such as remoting exceptions. However, the resulting XML files are _extremely_ large and virtually unreadable by humans. Not recommended for big datasets or permanent storage!

As for user-defined schemas, I don't see the point at all. The W3C Schema standard already defines basic data types such as integer or boolean, as well as sequences or choices of elements. Why reinvent the wheel? Defining a named instance of a custom type "Array", rather than just a complexType holding a sequence, seems like a useless complication to me.

Chris Nahr
Friday, February 20, 2004

if you have tools which can read an exsiting schema, it might be useful to use it.
or if you have unknown 'stuff', it's useful to use a <valpair><name>name</name><value>val</value></valpair> style--but that's creating a database in a database.

note that Apple's PList format is terrible--it's not really XML though it uses XML.

(it looks sometihng like <name>name</name><value>val</value><name>name2</name><value>val2</value>)

Friday, February 20, 2004

  <Property Name="prop 1" Value="..." />
  <Property Name="prop 2" Value="..." />

Duncan Smart
Saturday, February 21, 2004

*  Recent Topics

*  Fog Creek Home